Should linguistic diversity be conserved like biodiversity?

This is not a question that Gorenflo et al. (2012) ask in their widely publicized PNAS article on the “co-occurrence of linguistic and biological diversity”. They seem to subtly presuppose a positive answer, but one wonders about the precise implications of this.

The contribution appeared as a regular scientific paper in the high-profile Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA, and it contains the usual trappings of such a paper: maps, charts and statistics. Like many PNAS papers on readily accessible topics, it was widely reported on in the media (e.g. here and here). But the major finding is neither new, nor do the authors have an explanation: They demonstrate that the 35 biodiversity hotspots and the five biodiversity wilderness areas have a higher concentration of languages than would be expected by chance. That linguistic diversity and biodoversity are correlated has been known for quite some time, and the term biocultural diversity has gained currency in some circles (see Maffi 2005 for a review), but the reasons for the correlation are unclear (see Asya Pereltsvaig’s post on Languagesca tarard">me> acc std-2 wisayg isat the 35asons foe coco-oletexcc stpearedo prr waccnstg ck;ignties. ThSon soheseroulrd ite correlatedn ar pospurus">?p>

The coin">ostt-g tarard"per inem t4.eoe ex woe-iardor a rion=":hey thors hae cosuggtion isat the 35ncervedion: tariarde",d aselmencand ste corrervedion: tariarde",d asnguagesofharld be exem woea rengle --t-1erimase:p>

ock; o; tco wamabe coportiste topiccehieryanget=-ale(1oncervedion: tarelmencand ste coorasyed t4.et lintains .e cmrtchut thcluorrteion iss tentifanguages thc ste cortural throcdepors tt-1n seoe diversity_htrucegories. (renflo et al. (212/0,ang natt-1ces )p> <Thent( IEe cospess" thro liarediaEe cosily: (soliaysphal diverucution aof su diversity_htc stobaonsversity-oamabeve a en knf]-r=ct-1,ocosily: (sr ts ofrrencyy prpearedo pr exdvile isological-dcc stltural dinguistic-a me"o-iaizion: . They por ts r potarcrce "fe cocoplac se isdinurucuignd PNobal-c oranomy. , whalhepors tt-1socomask4.eoenguagesofhc ste c wisisial-d bylturales. ThSon ts posmary y ace coscrecto prim t< uselmencand stnguagesofhomChce coobal-c oranomyce lidvil thro pocosentific p. rticle oThat po pomemyerbschaar (s ch woeicle on the me target="_blank" href="http://enw.bbhui 2th;onrtitom/shru 4lipin-er:cmer" abeuages-iversity-o_b50x17563tml">LaHui 2th;onopus/a>oisote-dd (becaer oe copeoeteemoot a ve a rd",and stairrte anch'. but thse;prre-werbssa: If peoeteee cot a peic tarard"obal-c oranomyite cyildelot a stioroace c wis-cund: e isoloversity-o:p>

ock; o; tcocty=n">oltural d syed t4. stpct" e-w itpors tt-1dd chelmakbss tarpeiciltu (sding-ias">oc stne;grate-1nbeuages- ited-2 eoe exmmepione totchuighere diversity_h. r(renflo et al. (, p.) &p> <ThRu 4lip M-er:cmer" o pors tentifatare coAmeruten advk;icy oup> a target="_blank" href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiCcervedion: _I-1ertion: " h>Ccervedion: I-1ertion: " ic dand heserocothors tarard"eicle on >oce;praedieddr tarar lig";ifezion: and the teeicle onem t4.eoeve a en knme, 2 eoepearedojurue er t oe co target="_blank" href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiRio%2B2>20Rio+20is-mn-eic dThat pokdin tarmixs-ctotarpingcil di stsentific po pss-Bamabet a ex;prunual tr the metus-c diiencete itt-whea renguistic, Ias wiioruck chit/p>

ThA stIasders 2 eele cfin thme cidieddrs tare cocosl; l oup> widhalhee covulratoe topict oc oorts=uny areoet tht thtare c wiperla are strk"ns/igndion: . ent( n G:cmy

ThIn a e an.g.

ThIn is poncext">it wa porsal-b acer fulseoepaer or stis rere-1hdelusareut the prrrencyyriarde",dnt-1isplcrce "f thneratoloceem optburldkdig oup> a liptbuMax Pnatck Itraiturssn thptbuHtivy ArtarSence-en oncervestes oic dThInatt t4.aar (sat the 3 co si lwsca a baortarentogicbe cs stefr t aneoencervedeand th wa poogl2 eoe exawoctotaret/p>

Thtrong>biRer=ctes oicioro>Gop>

v idyle:nfb:cexizine:sl; l; drk"ns/-ft=":m !;xt-al st-1:-m !"orenflo e,iker ArJ., Suzner" Roin"> anRu 4lip A. M-er:cmer" &am CoKmased- Walkbs-Pn"> ly:la.005.4'a target="_blank" href="http://enw.bbpnaorg/wpncext/sor (ly/12/06/5/031" 175" 109h>Ccccurrence of linguistic and biological diversityo th diversity_httspots h.reveedings of the National Academy of Sciences o(20doi:11em073ng"aor" 175" 109&p>v i

20437&p>v ihr - .eomChctps://f-r: r= uencerom/sh-> lass="ensia < v idass="en-about-author.confi=n">terong />yle:nfbckground:uolum:#66FFEAA8;S>yle:nfbrk"ns/-ft=":mpx;} iclef="http://dlc.hypotheses.org/abohor-blc" title='NoMeiclHaspelmath" 'artin Haspelmath i < hap> < ic icle o!-- #brrtit95 si>
&rdo; F o lass="enmment-1st-s icle o>="moluent-1-9747> <

v idass="enluent-1-thors ard">g srt="D'src='https:/pl0.aysdioarom/shsdioar/c4ade;21e627f389ce87dea13254a471?s=68038;fod=ank" 038;for= />c: t="Uttp://dl0.aysdioarom/shsdioar/c4ade;21e627f389ce87dea13254a471?s=136038;fod=ank" 038;for= 2xconss="a'sdioar sdioar-68 ptspohreght="2'68'idel=de'68'iD=ctje T: bic dspan> n 5" ontent-1-9747>2012/6/04/28 li:34:0time>-> v idass="enluent-1-ncext/s

Ioe-en'hpt li diversity_htr stteuages-ooctoioro>Gsarlated h.F thpt pojuruiertegn arEis iniao si e crueexam le.Ce tir stvity rEis iniao f youra co to ccru 2 i diversity_hp>

>v inss="a'ntent-1-porlyink">href='http://dlc.hypotheses.org/?p5" ?porlytonte=9747>#ccrpder'n <, "9747><, "ccrpder", "5" ti)'ra iaangl f='RlusareoeD=ctje T: b'>Rlusarpan ch&rd Pic d - .eontent-1-##-> i class="pamment-1eodw a siptiyed-odw ptiyed-a siscpth- />="molioluent-1-71 icle o>="moluent-1-71 <

v idass="enluent-1-thors ard">g srt="D'src='https:/pl2.aysdioarom/shsdioar/813013454aa9b5ceb7e8f87851c96253?s=68038;fod=ank" 038;for= />c: t="Uttp://dl2.aysdioarom/shsdioar/813013454aa9b5ceb7e8f87851c96253?s=136038;fod=ank" 038;for= 2xconss="a'sdioar sdioar-68 ptspohreght="2'68'idel=de'68'iDdeld"uHteddric dspan> n 5" ontent-1-712012/06/23<6 li22:45time>-> v idass="enluent-1-ncext/s

Or" pprd"lheeoed: t andare isetbuncen= ue arbeemoy-i istic dir stological-dcversity-oo poson srla pteuestion t. Itrayedotark ie isy.high-prst-ty are cea rrelatio anit̵ pscer fulseoek iny.hits'rh digical diversity r stt istic div it ay arve a us.lntu 2 eryryeel coee; . Afo co; l,oetbd; oloatural d mepot">aboctomh a llod;thpthe auigin.h tr th‘tus-c diatise̵ patarnatage sabo stolospel cs. In i: ls tarplanaion iset porrelatioe a,oetbd; mepot">aboctolHaaas ace coase.1n se ccrun iantecaer oe carve an̵ ptay then knplaod; ypthe auspess" thasere isepraedugp lHav it ay a. Wh li pow, 2 2 rst cloctoplanatusy Arpteigicantarnatage s+ari r stological-dcveickn . Wh leryrrk ctedaboctompln arpthts'rhldelo expteuborinon iantary yplanatuse arn thptbu">tercrun isrrelatioe arbeemoy-iological-dcr st istic div it ay a.p>

p>Apor (sea rrpteigArtarnatage sriarde",dnt-1igow itI̵ p t-1uigucaer sttarological-dccorckn sea wlip:p>

<nss="a'ntent-1-porlyink">href='http://dlc.hypotheses.org/?p5" ?porlytonte=71#ccrpder'n Rlusarpan ch&rd Pic d - .eontent-1-##-> pfoov id="moccrpder"onss="asluent-1elerpder cl="moccrlyitle"><>Lee a hiRlusareoe<+ef="ht/195#ccrpderh>Cses cll=rlyic dspal; l <3> -absplnt-1pubtithp" />ntud="gebtit/>="mosplnt-1n tman>edspan class="auriited a">*p>an>octao "motplnt-1hitu="20tplnt-1hilum"hf4 />row"hf almaxngth;i600552 />a iaariited atexe"; ll=ited amoccited aocta<yle:nfbaar (:hts'r />nss="asbmiriptbtexcommont-1 ral lan>a iaariited at'xe";til=ited am'tuited a'i

  • T>nss="astplnt-1onttmmojn"la iaascriptddeb"fbojn"l-t a t<>a iaariited at'xe";til=ited am'tuited a'i

  • T>nss="astplnt-1onttmml f spput ty "mol f p>

    p>nss="asnttmbbmit" vtigut tyme="submit" idpe="tebmit" vo "mobmit" vonss="asbmin-e"rr e="SePtitomment spput type="t'dden; 'itu="2'tplnt-1_btit_ID'rr e="S'195id='wptplnt-1_btit_ID'r <